Welcome to Reynold's Pasty Shop, a hidden gem nestled in Milwaukee at 3525 W Burleigh St. This beloved establishment specializes in the perfect pasty—a savory pastry with roots in Michigan's Upper Peninsula that has found a home in Wisconsin. With a phone line open for inquiries at +1 414-444-4490, you won't want to miss out on this culinary delight.

Reynold's boasts a menu that caters to both the hungry and the adventurous. Their offerings include the Fresh N' Hot Pasty for just US$5.90, alongside a frozen option at US$5.35 which you can take home. For those looking to stock up, the Pasty by the Dozen is a fantastic value at US$58.75. Each bite delivers a burst of flavor, combining high-quality meats and fresh vegetables enveloped in perfectly baked pastry—an experience that has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.

What makes Reynold's truly special are the thoughtful add-ons they offer, like spicy whole pickles and a variety of hot sauces that elevate the pasty experience beyond your expectations. For dessert, indulge yourself with a slice of pecan pie or an apple turnover, both priced under US$3. These sweet indulgences are perfect for rounding off your meal and add an extra layer of delight.

Customers consistently rave about their experience at Reynold's. Beth Saltzman praises the “best pasties” she’s ever had, highlighting the exceptional service that accompanies each order—despite being a take-out only establishment. Chris G echoes this sentiment by calling the pasties “the best of the best in town.” Erik Smith shares that he’s enjoyed pasties from their birthplace up north, and he feels that Reynold's captures that authentic flavor and tradition right here in Milwaukee.

As you step into Reynold's Pasty Shop, you’ll immediately feel the warm, welcoming vibe that comes from a family-owned business dedicated to quality. The fast service ensures you won’t have to wait long to enjoy your hot pasty—sometimes ready in under 4 minutes! If you’re visiting or even living in the area, like Frannie Riedijk-Dean who took her pasties to Georgia, this is a must-visit spot that exemplifies the flavors and traditions that make pasties such a cherished dish.

In conclusion, Reynold's Pasty Shop is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a celebration of hearty, wholesome food that brings comfort and satisfaction. If you crave something genuine, flavorful, and uniquely Midwest, make sure to swing by and grab a pasty. You won’t just enjoy a meal; you’ll partake in a delightful culinary tradition.