Reynold's Pasty Shop Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Reynold's Pasty Shop, a hidden gem located at 3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, WI. This charming eatery specializes in traditional pasties, delivering authentic flavors reminiscent of Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Each pastry is crafted with fresh, savory ingredients, making it a fulfilling meal option. Customers rave about the exceptional quality and swift service, often expressing their admiration for the nostalgic recipes that transport them to culinary roots.

  • Menu Highlights:
  • Delicious pasties filled with a variety of meats and vegetables
  • Tempting add-ons like beef gravy and hot cheese to elevate your meal
  • A selection of refreshing drinks, including fruit punch and lemonade
  • Decadent desserst such as pecan pie and apple turnovers

Whether you're grabbing lunch on the go or taking a few pasties home, Reynold's Pasty Shop promises a delightful experience you won't soon forget!

PASTY ADD-ONs DRINKS DESSERTS

PASTY

Fresh N' Hot Pasty
US$5.90

Par-baked Pasty
US$5.35

Frozen Pasty
US$5.35

Pasty By The Dozen
US$58.75

Pasty By The Dozen (Day-Old Dozen)
US$45.05

Broken Pasty (24 pasties)

Only when available.
US$39.95

Hot Cheese
US$0.60

Beef Gravy
US$0.60

Sour Cream
US$0.60

Jalapeno Pepper (1)
US$0.55

Jalapeno Peppers (3)
US$1.05

Hot Sauce
US$2.10

Carrot & Onion Mix
US$1.05

Whole Pickle
US$1.00

Spicy Whole Pickle
US$1.10

ADD-ONs

DRINKS

Fruit Punch or Lemonade (Medium)
US$1.80

Fruit Punch or Lemonade (Large)
US$2.35

Pecan Pie Slice
US$2.35

Apple Turnover
US$2.25

DESSERTS